“Is it so bad that Bono does good?”

Comment:
I would like to thank you for your detailed and in-depth post about Bono and his efforts to battle the AID’s epidemic in Africa. I found your findings very informative because of the connection that is not highly publicized between American politics and celebrities. It is often not explained how much celebrities are really involved in various causes, and I found it refreshing to know Bono, was not just a face on the campaign but politically active as well. I was wondering what you thought of the RED campaign that became very popular within the last few years that Bono actually started. Do you think it was wrong for the RED campaign to use only celebrities in their ads, because I do not think all of those celebrities, such as Dakota Fanning and Jennifer Gardner, are as committed to the cause as Bono himself. Also, although Bono had made such great efforts to help the Aids foundations, his particular campaign has turned into a trend itself. I do not think that companies such as Apple and Motorola should be turning a profit because of the AIDs epidemic in Africa on their iPods and phones. I feel this campaign for Bono’s foundation, is just trendy. By having endorsed products, the focus has moved away from actually getting people involved in the cause. You had mentioned in your post that celebrities could hurt social issues and causes rather then helping them, if they are using the cause as a publicity stunt to cover up bad behavior. I thought this was a very good point and it made me rethink about the different celebrities that have used charities as a “cover-up” for their own problems. I was also wondering what your thoughts were about celebrities who are just donating money rather then taking an active political position on various issues? It is often publicized that pictures of newborn celebrity children are sold to magazines at a high price, and these profits are then donated to charity. I am not sure if this helps the cause but it defiantly seems unethical to me when the celebrities are selling their children’s picture and donating the money. This ploy, although it has raised massive amount of money, does not seem like it is really helping the cause.
“Celebrity Adoption-helping or Hurting the Adoption Community?”

Thank you for your post on the celebrity adoption issue. Adoption is very important, and I know in American society it may even be seen as taboo; but, with the influx of celebrities choosing to adopt children, which would otherwise grow up in bad conditions and or unhealthy environments, it is becoming more popularly accepted. Although I do think adoption is a great option, I myself do think that celebrities making adoption a trend is not always helpful. I feel theses orphans, in some cases, are being used as publicity stunt. You did mention Angelina Jolie as one of the celebrities who has adopted children, but when she adopted her first son Maddox, she did so right after her scandalous break up with her former husband Billy Bob Thorton. Secondly, Meg Ryan brought her child home years after from China after years of the tabloids has accusing her of cheating on her ex Dennis Quaid. Maybe these celebrities had always planned on adopting, but their timing was closely connected to when the media put a spotlight on their personal lives. Also, because of the emotional connections made when adopting a child, I was wondering if you thought that growing up in the spotlight is the best thing for these adopted children? I have a close friend who is adopted and growing up she told me that she and other adopted children she knew had problems grasping who they really were. I would imagine that growing up in the public eye, for an adopted child, would only make these children more out of touch with their place in the world. I do think that with the celebrities’ help of adopting children it has become more “normal”, which I think could better the adoption community. What I find the most concerning is that it is now a trend in Hollywood and adoption should not be trendy. The children are not little dogs that you can carry around in a purse. It is a serious commitment to take care of child and all that goes with it.
2 comments:
Great post Samie! You do a good job of raising potential problems with celebrity endorsement. The blogs you chose to comment at really add to your post, and your pictures do a nice job of illustrating your points. I liked how you engaged the author’s blog and provided your own insights into the matter. Your personal experience that you relayed in the adoption comment was a nice touch. On a quick side-note, you may want to include links to the blog post directly above the copies of your comments so that the reader doesn't have to backtrack to the top to actually view the post you are talking about. You may also want to provide a link back to your first post so that new readers can have easy access to your previous thoughts.
I definitely agree with your view of how celebrities tend to make causes trendy, which can detract from an issue, particularly when it comes to adoption. While I initially applauded Angelina Jolie for adopting a child, I was a bit overwhelmed by the string of adoptions (and then pregnancies) that followed. I feel doubtful that Jolie can provide adequate emotional support for all these children who, as you have pointed out, will grow up in a very big spotlight. Adoption is not something to be taken lightly, and I think you do a great job of pointing that out.
On the other hand, isn’t any media coverage sometimes better than no coverage at all? The mere fact that these celebrities are endorsing these causes brings them to the public’s attention, regardless of how dedicated these celebrities actually are. People may start out looking for a phone, but because of the RED campaign, they might end up finding out about AIDS in Africa and be drawn to do something about it. Granted, this is probably not a commonplace occurrence, but the more coverage an issue gets, the more people know about it and the more likely it is that they will start to do something about it. It may start out as a diversion tactic for the celebrity, but perhaps some good will come of it.
Thanks to you dear!! You have solved my problem, actually I have to submit my school project next week and the project is on the people who made the world better and I am searching on net and found your blog!!
Post a Comment